At 22:47 +0100 13/01/2003, scerir wrote:
>[George Levy]
>Here is a (white) hared brained idea
>on how to build a time machine.
>You need a very good recording device
>and a Quantum Suicide (QS) machine.
>
>For a simpler device see:
><http://www.fourmilab.ch/rpkp/chan-evid.html>http://www.fourmilab.ch/rpkp/chan-evid.html
>
>[Tim May]
>I am quite strongly persuaded that "many pasts
>for a particular present" is not a reality.
>
>I think GL is following Einstein (1931)
>and Wheeler (1978) here. The past has no
>evidence except as it is recorded at
>present. Hence, you can choose 'how' to
>observe this recorded past. By means of
>which set-up. And you can get different
>'pasts'.
Indeed. Something quite similar appears also
in Bell "one-world" interpretation of Everett's relative
state theory. This is discussed with some detailed
in Barrett's book, mentioned recently by Tim, "The quantum
mechanics of Mind and Worlds". (Oxford Press 1999)
(I have read that book quickly but my first feeling
is that Barrett did not understand the Everett's subjective
/objective distinction (akin to 1/3 person distinction).
I would follow GL (George Levy or Godel-Lob as you wish!)
on the many pasts, although I am not sure Bell's many past
are so coherent with Everett. Interesting matter anyway.
Bruno
Received on Tue Jan 14 2003 - 09:03:05 PST